The Science Behind Productive Mistakes
Shutterstock
By Zayna Dar, Founder, Shuhari Tuition
Mistakes have a reputation for being something students should avoid. In classrooms and at home, they’re often treated as signs that something has gone wrong, which can make students anxious and hesitant to try. Over time, this can lead to a reluctance or even fear of getting things wrong.
In reality, mistakes play a crucial role in developing students’ understanding of a concept. When they engage with challenging material, mistakes naturally emerge as part of the learning process. Learning accelerates when those mistakes are reflected upon and used to refine students’ understanding. This is what we mean by productive mistakes - errors that move learning forward rather than holding it back.
Understanding how and why mistakes can be useful helps parents, educators, and students respond to them more constructively as a tool for growth.
What happens in the brain when students get things wrong
When you make a mistake, your brain receives a signal that something didn’t match its prediction. This prediction error activates networks involved in attention and learning, particularly in the prefrontal cortex, which supports reasoning and decision making. Your brain pays close attention to these moments because they show that your current understanding needs adjusting.
As you reflect on the mistake and work out the correct answer, neural connections associated with the correct answer are strengthened. This process is supported by memory systems involving the hippocampus, which helps integrate new information with what is already known. Learning from mistakes often leads to stronger understanding because your brain has actively reorganised its knowledge instead of just reinforcing what it already assumed to be correct.
The emotional context surrounding mistakes also matters. When stress levels are high, working memory becomes overloaded. This makes it harder for students to understand where their thinking went wrong and how to improve next time. On the other hand, when students feel psychologically safe, stress levels remain low enough for learning systems to function effectively.
Why the fear of mistakes can slow academic progress
When students become afraid of making mistakes, learning becomes stagnant and driven by anxiety. Attention shifts away from trying to understand something and towards avoiding being wrong. Students stick to what feels safe instead of challenging themselves and disengage when work becomes difficult, which slows their progress.
Research shows that when anxiety occupies working memory, it becomes harder to concentrate, reason, and learn from feedback. The idea is therefore to create an environment where students feel safe to make mistakes.
The difference between surface errors and productive mistakes
Not all mistakes are created equal. Surface errors happen when attention slips or steps are rushed, like misreading a question or forgetting to add a unit of measurement. The understanding is usually there, but the final answer is incorrect, which can be frustrating for students.
Productive mistakes, by contrast, are made when a student stretches themselves. For example, when testing a method or applying knowledge in an unfamiliar context. These mistakes reveal how the student is thinking and where their understanding is still developing. In this sense, the mistake is doing useful work. It reveals exactly what needs refining.
Students often struggle to tell the difference between these two types of mistakes. Without guidance, they may interpret all mistakes as evidence they’re not good at a subject. This can lead them to avoid challenging tasks or stick to what feels easy. It’s when students begin to see mistakes as learning opportunities that they become willing to engage with difficult material and less afraid of getting things wrong.
For parents and educators, noticing the type of mistake matters too. Responding to surface errors with reassurance and double checking the student’s work with them can help them correct their errors without discouraging them.
How feedback turns mistakes into learning opportunities
Feedback plays an important role in helping students learn from mistakes. When students receive feedback that explains why an answer was incorrect and guides them towards finding the correct answer, the mistake is reframed as a useful part of the learning process. Mistakes become signals that learning is happening rather than setbacks. This type of feedback helps students adjust their thinking and strengthens their understanding over time.
Helping students respond constructively to mistakes
Helping students respond constructively to mistakes starts with normalising making mistakes as part of learning. Language that focuses on the student’s effort or progress, such as “This shows you’re starting to understand the idea, let’s build on it”, helps students stay receptive to feedback and keep trying even when the work feels difficult.
Students also benefit from being guided to reflect on what a mistake is showing them. Talking through what went wrong, what they were thinking at the time, and what they might try next builds confidence in their ability to learn from their mistakes. With this kind of support, students begin to develop resilience around mistakes. They learn that getting something wrong doesn’t mean they’re “bad” at a subject, it just means they’re in the middle of learning. This shift in mindset creates a healthier attitude towards making mistakes.
How learning from mistakes can make students stronger
When students are given the tools to understand their mistakes and see them as a natural part of learning, they start to see them as opportunities that help them grow. As parents and educators, we should strive to create a safe environment for learning and offer constructive guidance that gives students the space to approach challenges with confidence.
