Shutterstock
By Zayna Dar, Founder, Shuhari Tuition
We’ve seen many students internalise the belief that they’re falling behind, even when their behaviour and attitude suggest otherwise. Often these students attend lessons, complete assignments to the best of their ability, and demonstrate their understanding in assessments, yet still feel unsure of themselves. This is the confidence-competence gap, or the disconnect between a student’s belief in their ability to succeed and their actual ability.
It’s something that can be difficult for parents to understand because the evidence in front of them sometimes tell a different story. Their child might be achieving good marks while saying they’re ‘bad at maths’. They might complete their English homework to a high standard while believing everyone else is better at writing. They might understand a topic during a lesson but be convinced that they’ll forget everything as soon as they’re tested on the topic.
These feelings can be quite difficult for students because confidence affects how they experience learning. When a student believes they’re capable, they’re more likely to engage with tricky tasks and keep trying when something doesn’t immediately make sense. When they doubt themselves, however, tackling this task becomes far more intimidating.
A lack of self-belief can prevent capable students from reaching their full potential. Crucially, confidence influences engagement and achievement more than ability alone. A student who has the knowledge to succeed may still struggle to show what they know if they’re worried about getting the answer wrong. This means that supporting confidence is an important part of supporting academic progress.
This blog explores the confidence-competence gap and why a student’s perception of their ability doesn’t always match what they’re actually capable of. Understanding where this disconnect comes from will help parents and educators recognise when a student may be underestimating themselves and provide the right support to help them build greater trust in their own abilities.
Why confidence doesn’t always reflect ability
You often judge your own ability by what you see happening around you in the classroom. Students who raise their hand quickly or finish their work first may appear more capable, even when other students understand the material just as well. If you’re a quieter student who takes longer to answer, you may start to assume that you know less simply because you’re less comfortable speaking up.
This can be especially difficult if you need more time to process information. You may understand a topic fully but still hesitate before giving an answer. If you regularly compare this with classmates who finish the work quicker or raise their hand more often in class, you can begin to mistake speed and confidence for ability.
You may also become fixated on the moments when you struggle, remembering the question you couldn’t answer in class while forgetting the many questions you answered correctly. You might remember receiving a low mark on one assessment and overlook the improvement you made in another. This creates a distorted picture of your progress where you continually underestimate yourself.
Confidence is closely connected to the story you tell yourself about your ability. If you repeatedly tell yourself that you’re ‘behind’, eventually you’ll start to believe it. A difficult homework question or a mistake in a test become evidence that you’re not good at the subject. But if you do this, you’re drawing conclusions about yourself based on limited information.
This is why it’s important to look beyond your results. A mistake tells you something about a gap in your knowledge or an improvement needed in your exam technique, but it doesn’t tell you everything about your ability. Sometimes you need someone else to help you see this distinction.
A tutor plays an important role here because they have the opportunity to observe how you approach learning. They notice the progress you make, which is easy for you to miss when you’re more focused on what you need to improve.
How comparison impacts self-belief
The classroom environment naturally invites comparison. Students notice who contributes to class discussions and who receives praise from the teacher. Even when teachers don’t intend to encourage comparison, students become very aware of how they compare with their classmates and where they think they rank academically.
This affects students in different ways. If you regularly see one of your classmates finish their work quickly, you may assume they’re smarter than you because they understand everything instantly. But what you don’t see is how much studying that student has done at home to get to grips with the topic. You also don’t know if that student finds a different topic in that subject difficult. In effect, you’re comparing your own complete experience with a small part of someone else’s.
Social media adds to this phenomenon. You’re constantly exposed to carefully selected versions of other people’s lives. You might hear that a friend achieved a high mark in a test or see someone celebrating their results and immediately question your own. The problem is that you don’t see the work that went into that achievement or the areas where that person might be struggling. You simply see the outcome, so you may assume that everyone else is doing better than you.
For those who already lack confidence, this has a big impact on how they see themselves. You may start to believe that other students are more capable than you or you’re the only person who needs extra help. Even when there’s no real evidence to support these beliefs, repeated comparisons makes them seem true.
Comparison also makes you focus on where you think you should be rather than recognising where you are now. You may have made significant progress but still feel disappointed because someone else got a higher grade than you. This makes it difficult for you to recognise your own achievements.
Everyone has different strengths and areas they find more challenging. One student may understand a new topic quickly but struggle with a different one later in the course. Another student may need more time to understand a concept at first but develop a much stronger understanding once it’s clicked. Learning doesn’t happen at exactly the same pace for everyone.
This is especially important for those who need more time to process information. Taking longer to answer a question or needing something explained again doesn’t mean you’re less capable. However, if you constantly compare yourself with classmates who appear to understand things more quickly, you may start to believe that it does.
Instead of asking yourself whether you’re doing as well as someone else, it’s more useful to ask yourself whether you understand something now that you found difficult before. This helps you develop a more realistic view of your abilities that takes into account your own progress rather than measuring yourself against somebody else’s.
The role of feedback
Feedback has a powerful influence on how you see yourself as a learner. The comments you receive from your teachers, tutors, and parents shape the way you see your successes and failures. If you already lack confidence, you may pay particular attention to anything that suggests you could have done better while overlooking the things you did well.
Imagine getting a piece of marked homework back with several corrections. You might immediately focus on everything you got wrong and come away thinking that you’re not very good at the subject. You may overlook the fact that you got most of the questions correct or that you understood a concept that you’d previously struggled with. Your attention goes straight to the area you need to work on, causing you to lose sight of where you’ve actually improved.
You may develop the sense that no matter how hard you work and how much effort you put in, there will always be something to improve. This can have a negative effect on your motivation and make you question whether you’re even capable of making progress and achieving your academic goals.
In this case, what matters is how feedback is given. Telling a student that they need to improve isn’t particularly helpful if they don’t understand what they need to improve or how they can do it. Specific feedback is necessary to give you something you can act on. If you’re told that your answer needs more detail, for example, you can work on developing your reasoning and including enough points to meet the marking criteria.
It’s important you take the time to recognise what you’ve done well. Of course, this doesn’t mean getting everything right every time. In fact, praise can sometimes feel meaningless if it isn’t connected to anything specific. When your teacher or tutor points out exactly what you’ve done well, you have evidence that you’re capable in that subject.
For example, they might point out that you followed all the steps of a method correctly when previously you’d struggled to do so. You might not have noticed this yourself because you were more focused on the questions you found difficult. The feedback helps you see progress you would’ve otherwise overlooked.
This is where feedback can help close the confidence-competence gap. You begin to see that your ability isn’t defined by the questions you get wrong. You can recognise there are areas you still need to work on while also understanding that you already have a strong foundation to build from.
Mistakes are an important part of this process. If you treat every mistake as proof you’re not capable, you’re likely to become more hesitant when faced with something difficult. You may avoid answering questions because you don’t want to get them wrong or second-guess yourself when you arrive at an answer. You may even decide that you’re simply not good at the subject.
A more useful way to think about mistakes is to see them as information. They show you where you went wrong and give you an opportunity to understand what you need to work on. Feedback should help you make sense of your mistakes so that you can learn from them. This also changes the way you respond to the challenges you face in the future.
If you know that getting something wrong doesn’t mean you’re incapable, you’re more likely to have another go. You become more willing to ask questions when you’re unsure. You start to approach difficult topics with the understanding that you may not get everything right immediately, and that’s okay.
For parents, this means thinking carefully about the feedback given at home as well. If every conversation after a test centres on the grade your child achieved, they may begin to believe that their performance is the most important factor when it comes to their learning.
Asking them what they understood, what they found difficult, and what they feel more confident in creates a more balanced picture. Good feedback should help you understand where you are in your learning, giving you a clearer idea of what you can already do and what you need to work on next.
How students can rebuild confidence
If you truly believe you’re not capable, being told that you are capable may not be enough to close the confidence-competence gap and change how you see yourself. You need opportunities to experience success and recognise that success for yourself. One way to do this is to focus on the progress you’ve made. Think about what you can do now that you couldn’t do before.
This might be something small, like attempting a question without help. Moments like these may not feel important at the time, but they provide evidence that you’re heading in the right direction. When you begin to notice these changes, you have something more reliable to base your confidence on than comparison or a single test result.
It may help to break larger goals into smaller, manageable ones to reduce feelings of overwhelm. A smaller goal gives you something achievable to work towards. For example, in maths you might learn how to interpret different command words so that you know exactly what each question is asking of you before tackling the questions themselves. Each step gives you an opportunity to build your knowledge and confidence.
If you’ve repeatedly told yourself that you’re ‘bad at maths’, for example, you’ll approach every maths less with a defeatist attitude. This creates a self-fulfilling prophecy: you expect yourself to struggle, which makes it more likely you do struggle. You might avoid attempting a difficult question because you’re worried about getting it wrong and you’ve already decided you won’t be able to solve it. You might give up more quickly when something doesn’t make sense or avoid asking for help because you don’t want to draw attention to what you perceive as a weakness.
This self-fulfilling prophecy influences your behaviour. If you believe you’re going to get something wrong, you may put less effort into attempting it. If you expect to struggle, you may become more anxious when you encounter something difficult. Then, when you do struggle, it serves as confirmation that your original belief was correct. This is how the confidence-competence gap becomes difficult to bridge. Your belief about your ability affects your behaviour, your behaviour affects your performance, and that performance then reinforces the original belief.
Changing this pattern takes time and requires a different way of talking to yourself. Rather than making a judgement about your ability, try to describe what’s actually happening. ‘I don’t understand how to work this out’ is very different from ‘I’m not good at this’. The first statement identifies a problem that can be worked on. The second turns a temporary difficulty into a judgement about yourself.
Try to become comfortable with not knowing something straight away. Learning often involves confusion, mistakes, and moments where you need to try again. If you expect yourself to get the hang of something immediately, you might interpret difficulty as evidence that you aren’t capable. In reality, difficulty is often a normal part of learning something unfamiliar.
This is where asking for help is essential. Some students avoid asking questions because they worry that admitting they don’t understand something will make them look less capable. However, there’s a big difference between needing support with something and being unable to do it.
You may also benefit from keeping track of your progress. This could be as simple as recording the topics you’ve found difficult and revisiting them after a period of study to see if your understanding has improved. A tutor can support this process by helping you identify what you’ve improved in, what still needs attention, and what the next steps should be. Remember that needing to improve in one area doesn’t cancel out the progress you’ve made in another.
Learning to trust the process
Building confidence in a subject takes time, especially if you’ve spent years underestimating yourself. If you already think you’re behind, one good test result or some praise from your teacher is unlikely to undo that ingrained belief. It’s possible you still question your ability next time you find something difficult or compare yourself with a classmate when they get a higher score than you in a class test.
Changing your mindset requires patience and a willingness to keep challenging your assumptions about yourself. You may still have moments where you doubt yourself, but you can begin to recognise those moments without letting them shape your view of what you’re capable of.
Learning to trust the process means accepting that your confidence won’t always match your ability. There will be times when you feel unsure, particularly when you’re learning something new or challenging. What matters is allowing yourself to keep learning without assuming that difficulty means you aren’t capable.
The confidence–competence gap can be bridged when the way you see yourself catches up with what you’re actually capable of. This happens when you start to pay attention to your progress and trust that you can do difficult things.
